When Yellowstone aired its midseason finale back in January 2023, the future was looking ominous for the Dutton family on the fifth season of the Paramount Network mega-hit series. For a refresher, Jamie Dutton (Wes Bentley) had just thrown down the gauntlet against his sister Beth Dutton (Kelly Reilly) and father John Dutton (Kevin Costner) in a move that would usher in an all-out war between the embittered family members. Will Jamie kill Beth? Or will John kill Jamie first? Those were the high-stakes questions sitting with viewers.
Then, the fate of TV’s biggest show changed course.
Behind the scenes, a scheduling dispute with Yellowstone star and patriarch Costner ushered in a months-long production delay on the second half of season five. The cast and crew had been planning to resume filming in March 2023 with an announced summer premiere date, but those dates came and went. Not until early May of 2023 would the network announce that Yellowstone was going back into production, but that the remaining episodes — which were then set for a November 2023 debut — would mark an abrupt ending to the beloved neo-Western saga and flagship series. There were, however, new plans to continue the Dutton dynasty (which already counts spinoffs 1923 and 1883 in its stable) with a Yellowstone sequel series that, at the time, was widely reported to star Matthew McConaughey and debut in December 2023.
That announcement, however, came just days after the May 2 writers strike, which would usher in the July 13 SAG-AFTRA strike; the rare 2023 double strike effectively shutting down Hollywood productions and grinding U.S.-produced series — including Yellowstone — to a halt.
The status of the final episodes of Yellowstone were then locked in the barn for months — until the flagship series was given a November 2024 premiere date send-off following the resolution of the strikes and Costner dispute (ultimately leading to his departure being made official). But, don’t worry, the Yellowstone-verse will continue on — the aforementioned sequel series has now been given a new title — The Madison — and a new A-list star to lead and executive produce — Michelle Pfeiffer — and there are also reports that suggest these season 5B episodes may not be the end of the flagship series after all.
Below, The Hollywood Reporter is keeping track of everything as it develops about the series, co-created by Yellowstone-verse boss Taylor Sheridan, as it rides off into the night.
When Will the Season 5B Episodes Air?
When this all began, we initially predicted: “Most likely, sometime in 2024.” And, we were right. The second half of the final season will air Nov. 10 at 8 p.m. on Paramount Network, with an encore two hours later on CBS.
Production was slated for late spring 2024 and, on May 20, the network announced that production had finally begun in Montana on what has been believed to be the final episodes (more on that, below).
Before two of Hollywood’s biggest guilds, WGA and SAG-AFTRA, found themselves in a standoff with the studios, Yellowstone had not yet begun production. The scripts from creator Sheridan, who writes the entire series, were not yet complete. (April to October is when they typically shoot, with snowy Montana winters complicating filming on the heavily outdoor series.) Sheridan began working on the scripts once the writers strike resolved in September 2023.
Now, scripts are complete and filming is underway. An episode count has yet to be confirmed.
Why Did Kevin Costner Exit the Series?
Months before the writers strike was called, reports of Costner wanting to exit the series sent a jolt through the Yellowstone-verse. How could TV’s biggest hit continue without its Oscar-winning lead?
In late March 2023, president and CEO of Showtime/MTV Entertainment Studios Chris McCarthy, spoke to those fears when he told The Hollywood Reporter that Yellowstone “wouldn’t be what it is today without Kevin and we hope that that stays for a long time to come.” Flash forward to May of 2023, when viewers were told that Costner would be staying on the series but that the series is ending. But the still-looming question remained: In what capacity will viewers see John Dutton? (McCarthy later told THR: “This Yellowstone chapter is closing sooner than we all wanted, but we feel good with where it’s going to end.”)
In late June 2023, Sheridan sat down with THR for a rare cover story where he opened up about the scheduling clash, shedding light on the source of the delay: Costner wanted to focus on his own Western epic, a four-movie passion project titled Horizon that he co-wrote, directed and starred in (and went on to premiere at 2024 Cannes in May 2024; the first film hit theaters June 2024). “He and the network were arguing about when he could be done with Yellowstone. I said, ‘We can certainly work a schedule toward [his preferred exit date],’ which we did,” said the prolific TV hitmaker. “But once lawyers get involved, then people don’t get to talk to each other and start saying things that aren’t true and attempt to shift blame based on how the press or public seem to be reacting. He took a lot of this on the chin and I don’t know that anyone deserves it. His movie seems to be a great priority to him and he wants to shift focus. I sure hope [the movie is] worth it — and that it’s a good one.”
Cover story writer James Hibberd had reported that there were ongoing discussions to try to convince Costner to film a few scenes to wrap his character. Sheridan hinted that John Dutton was never going to be around for the very end of the show in his original script. Still, the creator admitted, “I’m disappointed. It truncates the closure of his character. It doesn’t alter it, but it truncates it.”
In early September 2023 during a divorce hearing from wife Christine Baumgartner, Costner went on the record for the first time about the dispute, saying he might take the show to court. Per reports, Costner claimed he’s owed $12 million for the second half of season five after Paramount “walked away” from negotiations. “We tried to negotiate, they offered me less money than previous seasons [and] there were issues with the creative,” he said.
As for whether or not that meant Sheridan would write Costner totally off the series — and deliver him an off-camera fate — media newsletter Puck reported that Sheridan did just that and wrote the post-strike back half of season five without John Dutton. Months later, in April 2024, Costner made his first public comments on his Yellowstone fate, implying that there was still a chance Sheridan could revisit the script while at CinemaCon promoting Horizon: An American Saga. “But that’s Taylor’s thing,” he said. “I said as much to him a while back. I had thoughts how it could happen, but we just have to see.”
But, with Costner still not involved at that late stage with scripts complete and production underway, the writing seemed to be on the wall. When speaking to THR‘s Awards Chatter podcast in May 2024, Costner said that, from his perspective, the scripts for the second-half of season five weren’t ready in time before he had to start on Horizon. “I couldn’t break my word with actors that I made promises with, and a promise I made to myself. It doesn’t matter how much money you throw at me,” he said.
Then in June 2024, Costner all-but confirmed he wasn’t involved — but still left the door slightly ajar. “I would love to go back under the right circumstances I think that all of us want,” he said on the Today. Later telling People he was disappointed that no one came to his defense as this has played out in the press but still, if the script feels right, “I would step into it if I agreed with how it was being done.”
Not until June 20 did Costner finally and officially confirm, after all the speculation, that he has indeed walked away from the role of John Dutton. “After this long year and a half of working on Horizon and doing all the things that that’s required and thinking about Yellowstone, that beloved series that I love, that I know you love, I just realized that I’m not going to be able to continue, season five or into the future,” he said in a video to his social media. “I loved it and I know you loved it, and I just wanted to let you know that I won’t be returning. I love the relationship we’ve been able to develop, and I’ll see you at the movies.”
How Many Episodes Will There Be?
An official episode count has yet to be confirmed by the network. Sheridan, who was pencils down in support of the WGA’s efforts when speaking to THR for the cover story, suggested at that time that he might make more than the previously reported six final episodes. “If I think it takes 10 episodes to wrap it up, they’ll give me 10,” Sheridan says. “It’ll be as long as it needs to be.”
What Will Yellowstone Look Like Without John Dutton?
Yellowstone has built a sprawling cast of characters whom viewers have come to know and root for across the show’s five seasons. And while the biggest storyline when the show left off was indeed centered around the battle between Beth and Jamie — with Montana Gov. John Dutton squarely putting himself on Beth’s side — the feud certainly set up the possibility that John could be quickly taken to the “train station” (the Dutton code term for where they bury the bodies of their enemies).
When speaking in June after the writers strike but ahead of the actors strike, Bentley told THR he hadn’t talked to Costner and hadn’t yet seen any scripts, but that he had given much thought to how the the fate of the characters might play out.
“Does Jamie go down with John? Does John go down because of Jamie? Does Jamie have a hand in it at all, or does it turn out Jamie tries to protect him? There are so many potential ways he deals with John’s ending,” he said. “We’re at a point where I think everything is possible with the Duttons. It’s so hot and combustible right now that it could blow them all up together. I think the potential for that is real. But I also know that I am always surprised by Taylor and the turns and directions. With the tension and danger right now, it potentially could be either they are all gone, or one of them survives.”
John’s departure would also leave room to highlight more of the ensemble of characters, which includes Kayce (Luke Grimes) and Monica Dutton (Kelsey Asbille), Chief Thomas Rainwater (Gil Birmingham) and right-hand man Mo (Mo Brings Plenty), Rip Wheeler (Cole Hauser) and the cowboys in the Dutton’s bunkhouse (played by Forrie J. Smith, Denim Richards, Ian Bohen, Jake Ream, Ryan Bingham and Jen Landon), as well as newer antagonists played by Dawn Olivieri and Piper Perabo.
Grimes recently said he understood Costner’s decision to prioritize Horizon, but called it “unfortunate” for the story. “Whatever happened there is unfortunate if it’s changed anything about how the show was going to unfold,” he said. It has previously been reported that Costner wanted to approve his character’s fate in the series, but Sheridan — like most showrunners — doesn’t typically let actors determine how their character’s storylines end.
Are There Clues in the Season 5B Trailer?
The return of Yellowstone is so secretive that not even the cast knows how it’s all going to play out. The show’s stars recently revealed that scripts were redacted so the actors would only know their own lines, eliciting real-time reactions in some cases as they filmed.
Given how little has been revealed about the plot and what the show will look like without Costner, the biggest hints at what to expect now come in the newly released, explosive official trailer (below).
Taking many viewers by surprise, Costner very much appears in the first look, both in visuals and in voice over, as he says in what appears to be a conversation with Rip, “Everyone’s forgotten who runs this valley. Time to remind them.” He ends the trailer by saying, “This war is just beginning.”
Dutton family conflict threatens to boil over in the scenes featured, as Beth pushes back (“I can’t do this anymore,” she says, to which Rip replies, “Well, you’re gonna have to, honey. Or we’re gonna lose this place”) and brothers Kayce and Jamie get physical in a blink-and-you’ll-miss-it scene. Olivieri, who plays fixer Sarah Atwood and Jamie’s love interest, also issues Jamie a threat, and gets physical with Beth.
What Is the Future of the Franchise?
The Yellowstone-verse isn’t slowing down. In fact, it’s only ramping up. With the flagship reigning as the most-watched series across cable and broadcast, Paramount Network previously confirmed that two more spinoffs are in the works: The Madison (formerly 2024), a present-day story, and another prequel, 1944, that will follow in the footsteps of 1883 and 1923.
The Madison will star Michelle Pfeiffer, and it will be the next series to rollout in the Yellowstone universe. When initially titled 2024, the series was described as a sequel that would take place after the events of Yellowstone. With Pfeiffer’s casting announcement (she will also executive produce), here’s how the series was described: “A heartfelt study of grief and human connection following a New York City family in the Madison River valley of central Montana.” Matthew Fox, Patrick J. Adams, Beau Garrett, Elle Chapman, Ben Schnetzer and Amiah Miller round out the cast.
A possible sixth season of the flagship series, meanwhile, has also been reported, with Reilly and Hauser in talks to star as the married fan-favorites Beth and Rip. Paramount Network has not commented.
After setting ratings records and launching multiple star-driven spinoffs (Faith Hill and Tim McGraw, as well as Harrison Ford and Helen Mirren now count themselves among the Duttons), the ranch drama has sparked a Western genre craze and has become a model for a new wave of franchise-building.
The franchise’s second prequel series, 1923, was renewed for a second and final season before the strike and the sequel series was announced to be airing in tandem with the final season of Yellowstone (it remains to be seen if those plans will remain, but the series is currently in production). Sheridan had confirmed to THR that he was planning several more prequels; and 1944 is the first to be confirmed. (The previously announced Four Sixes series, which was set to follow Yellowstone cowboy Jimmy, played by Jefferson White, is on hold.) “I think there will be enough for many more [prequels] — three or four,” he said. “Chris McCarthy trusts me, because I haven’t been wrong yet.”
Where Will the Sequel Series Jump?
The follow-up installment, now titled The Madison, was given a straight-to-series order and will stream on Paramount+ (at some point in the future). Sheridan had hinted in THR‘s cover story that the spinoff — which would be the first to take place after the events of Yellowstone — might lean on an entirely new cast and location, but it has since been announced that the series will continue exploring the Dutton family dynasty with new characters and locations, as well as some existing characters. That has sparked speculation about what other familiar faces will pop up.
There is no official word on which Yellowstone stars will return, but Hauser recently hinted that his Rip and Reilly’s Beth could play a part in the sequel.
Details on 1944 are also scarce at the moment, but the creator had hinted that his approach would be similar to that taken with the prequels, which functioned as stand-alone stories within the generational family tree. “There are lots of places where a way of life that existed for 150 years is slamming against a new way of life, but the challenges are completely different. There are a lot of places you can tell this story,” he said.
James Hibberd contributed to this story.
This story originally posted July 2023 and is updated as news develops.
Source: Hollywoodreporter
