The Top 10 ‘South Park’ Christmas Episodes, Ranked

With its climactic “Christmas miracle” inversion, this parody of underdog sports movies obliterates every expected emotional payoff in the gleeful South Park fashion that we know and love. In the episode, Christmas cheer is weaponized as emotional misdirection when the dying child protagonist simply dies at the end. It remains one of South Park’s darkest comedic sucker punches and remains questioned on message boards and among fans as the possible moment that Trey Parker and Matt Stone went too far. A deliberate rejection of holiday warmth that you can take or leave, just be warned that you’ll be walking into a bold and perhaps cruel anti-sentimentality statement. 

With its climactic “Christmas miracle” inversion, this parody of underdog sports movies obliterates every expected emotional payoff in the gleeful South Park fashion that we know and love. In the episode, Christmas cheer is weaponized as emotional misdirection when the dying child protagonist simply dies at the end. It remains one of South Park’s darkest comedic sucker punches and remains questioned on message boards and among fans as the possible moment that Trey Parker and Matt Stone went too far. A deliberate rejection of holiday warmth that you can take or leave, just be warned that you’ll be walking into a bold and perhaps cruel anti-sentimentality statement. 

While the Marsh family winds up sharing holiday travel with escaped serial killer Charles Manson, Cartman manipulates the town into turning Christmas into a capitalist free-for-all. Credit is deserved for the portrayal of Manson, not as monstrous or charismatic, but as pathetic and absurd, which takes away his mythical status that makes him an object of fascination for so many. This early episode was also an early display of Cartman’s manipulative nature, which has come to define the character we all love to hate…so much. 

Trey Parker’s songwriting talent is fully showcased here, foreshadowing his Broadway success to come in an episode structured as a musical anthology hosted by, of course, Mr. Hankey. This episode delivers a full slate of Christmas song parodies, ranging from feline sacrilege to some uncomfortably sincere holiday ballads. The episode has no single central narrative to thread it together, but its strength lies in its music and Parker’s raw talent. Many of its songs became cult classics within the South Park fanbase, replayed annually around the holidays. It also stands as a transitional moment as South Park moved from raw shock comedy to a more polished comedic production style.

In what works as both a send-up and love letter to the “animagic” stop-motion Christmas specials of Arthur Rankin and Jules Bass, South Park goes full claymation for its fourth-season holiday episode. Mr. Hankey is back and in a more natural form as he battles broadcast standards and moral gatekeeping while Jesus and Frosty come to blows over the commercialization of the holiday. While the episode runs the risk of spreading its themes thin by balancing too many at once, the writers stick the landing… and lock Mr. Hankery into the show’s annual holiday identity, rather than leaving him as a one-off season one gag. 

When baby Ike is kidnapped to Canada, Kyle and the gang high-tail it through a snowbound mythological version of Great White North, encountering beavers, monsters, and, it being 2003 South Park, a perpetually troubled couple, Saddam Hussein and Satan, along the way. The Terrance and Phillip-style animation shift here gives this holiday episode an experimental feel, and the geopolitical parody remains sharp as it fits directly into the holiday rescue plot. The boys’ journey gives this one an adventurous structure and there’s plenty of world-building akin to a fantasy epic (the Lord of the Rings trilogy was all the rage at the time) than a sitcom bottle episode.

This very-post-9/11-attacks episode defines that dark era with a reimagining of Santa Claus as a prisoner of war being tortured by then-Iraqi leader Saddam Hussein. The South Park kids launch a full-scale rescue of captive Kringle using military hardware scavenged by none other than the birthday boy himself, Jesus Christ. This morphing of real-world geopolitics into absurdist Christmas warfare deftly skewers American interventionism, the logic of propaganda, and the good-vs-evil (with no gray areas) binary that permeated that time in American history. The Iraq War became a large topic during South Park’s earlier seasons and the show’s satirical image of Santa delivering vengeance via a fighter jet has endured. “Red Sleigh Down” is where South Park proved it had some bitingly sharp satirical chops around global politics — the very same chops that bit into the Trump Administration recently in its comeback two-season run, which served as a breath of fresh air amid the frigid chill of Trump 2.0’s early days.

Who could ask for a more handsome, adept, and merchandising-friendly holiday mascot than South Park’s very own Mr. Hankey? In the episode that set up South Park and the Christmas holiday as longtime companions, the anthropomorphized turd has his grand introduction to the world by Kyle, as he escapes Mr. Garrison’s nativity play amid his mother’s wrath. The episode doles out what have now become a few classic moments and songs, starting with Kyle’s lament, “A Jew on Christmas.” Scolded by his parents for insisting his “make-believe” friend exists, Mr. Hankey goes full Michigan J. Frog and won’t come to life when anyone walks in on his song-and-dance numbers. The late 1990s’ wave of political correctness gets a send-up, the Cartman classic “Kyle’s Mom is a Bitch” debuts, and the townsfolk get into a massive brawl before our hero, Mr. Hankey, steps in to save the day with a speech about the spirit of Christmas. And with it, a star is born. And in a real Christmas miracle, Kenny survives to see the end of his first South Park episode.

This is the one. South Park has rarely been so cleverly structured, outrageously devilish, whiplash-inducing, or as shocking — even for them — than this fan and critic’s favorite. What transpires in this rug-pull of a Christmas episode is subversive in its Satanic holiday theme, innovative in its framing as a classroom-read fable (by a “shoulda seen it coming” source), and bounty-pushing in the show’s spirit and high stakes at Stan thwarts the apocalypse.

It begins as a narrated telling of a wholesome holiday fable, in which an increasingly reluctant Stan helps some sweet, adorable, talking woodland critters he stumbles upon as they prepare for the arrival of their savior, after Porcupiney the Porcupine becomes pregnant by immaculate conception. The reveal arrives after it is tricked into killing the apparent big bad villain of this woodland crew, a local mountain lion, and the cutesy crew celebrates with a Satanic blood orgy. That’s right, Porcupiney is to birth the son of Satan and soon Kyle is to embody the Anti-Christ. The rest, involving a gun-toting Santa and abortion-performing lion cubs, set a high-water benchmark for South Park’s holiday oeuvre that has yet to be surpassed.